To Soak or Not to Soak: The Ultimate Seed Starting Guide

A Peek Behind the Scenes of Our Small Business

Getting a head start on the gardening season often feels like a race against the clock. One of the most common "shortcuts" gardeners discuss is seed soaking. While it can shave days off germination time, it’s not a universal rule. Doing it to the wrong seeds can actually lead to rot and failure.

Here is everything you need to know about when to reach for the water bowl and when to keep things dry.

Unlike soft-coated varieties, seeds with hard shells benefit most from a 12-to-24-hour soak to ensure successful germination.

Why Soak Seeds at All?

In nature, seeds often have a hard outer shell (the seed coat) designed to protect the embryo inside until conditions are perfect. This shell prevents water from entering too early.

By soaking seeds, you are essentially "tricking" the seed into thinking a heavy rain has arrived. This process, called imbibition, softens the seed coat, allowing moisture to reach the embryo and kickstart the metabolic processes required for growth.

When to Soak Seeds

You should consider soaking seeds that are large, wrinkled, or have a very hard, woody exterior. These seeds naturally take a long time to absorb enough moisture to sprout.

Ideal Candidates for Soaking:

• Large Legumes: Peas, Beans, and Chickpeas.

• Hard-Coated Flowers: Sweet Peas, Lupines, Morning Glories, and Nasturtiums.

• Slow Germinators: Parsley, Beets (which are actually clusters of seeds), and Chard.

• Large Veggies: Squash, Pumpkins, and Corn (though often optional, it speeds things up).

The "Sweet Spot" Method:

1. Use Lukewarm Water: Not boiling, just slightly warm to the touch.

2. Timing is Everything: Aim for 12 to 24 hours.

3. Don't Overdo It: Soaking for more than 24 hours can actually "drown" the seed by depriving the embryo of oxygen, leading to rot.

A glass of garbanzo beans (chick peas) soaking prior to sowing.

When NOT to Soak Seeds

Soaking isn't always beneficial. In many cases, it makes the seeds nearly impossible to plant or ruins their chances of survival.

1. Tiny Seeds

Tiny seeds like Carrots, Lettuce, Oregano, or Poppies should never be soaked. Once wet, they clump together, making it impossible to space them correctly. Furthermore, many tiny seeds are "light-dependent" and need to be on the soil surface; soaking them often leads to them being buried too deep.

2. Mucilaginous Seeds

Some seeds, such as Chia, Basil, and Flax, develop a gelatinous, gooey coating when they get wet. If you soak these, you’ll end up with a sticky mass that is impossible to sow individually.

3. Pelleted Seeds

If you bought seeds that have a colorful, clay-like coating (common with carrots or petunias), do not soak them. This coating is designed to dissolve slowly in the soil to provide consistent moisture and nutrients. Soaking will just melt the coating away prematurely.

Scarification

Expert Tip: The Scarification Combo

For seeds with exceptionally tough coats (like Morning Glories), soaking works best if you scarify them first. Use a piece of sandpaper or a nail file to gently nick the seed coat before dropping it into the water. This allows the water to bypass the "armor" immediately.

Happy planting!